This is so myopic. The one-issue voters (or non-voters) who let Trump win ignored the fact that not only would he not make things better for Palestinians, he’d end democracy and try to oppress and wipe out everyone who isn’t a straight white cis male Christian Nationalist. They ignored it then and this Zirin person is ignoring it in his argument now. “Biden was bad too” is not an excuse.
In my opinion, for people worried about Palestinians, it was a no-win scenario- Trump is horrible but Harris also would have been bad. Sometimes that happens- sometimes you don’t get what you want, and there’s no way to avoid it. The adult thing to do in that case is not to take your ball and go home, it’s to vote strategically, for the best future you can manage, because voting is not a fucking game and there are real consequences for everyone, not just for whichever cause is most important to you personally.
I knew that I wouldn’t be getting meaningful progress on issues important to me no matter which way I voted, yet I still did my part and voted for Harris because I’m not a goddamn self-absorbed monster who is willing to let the world burn because I didn’t get my way on those issues. People who didn’t turn out to fight Trump did exactly that, sacrificing everything including the very cause they claim to care about, all because they couldn’t deal with not getting instant gratification from either candidate. Yes, the Democrats aren’t progressive enough, yes, Biden’s administration was supporting genocide, yes, our system is broken and corrupt, yes, some of us have been voting for decades and seeing things slowly decay instead of getting better, even when we win. NONE OF THAT EXCUSES LETTING A FUCKING NAZI BECOME DICTATOR! Despite all Zirin’s hand-wringing, this was NOT a hard decision to make, and they fucked it up. They have the blood of far more than just Palestinians on their hands now.
But my issue isn’t whether the rest of us should call them out for that behavior. Personally, I don’t care whether or not people choose to go online and scold them. My issue is that forgiving them, trying to build a united front with them, is dangerous. These people fucked up so badly, on an issue where the choice was so blindingly obvious, that I cannot see myself ever trusting them. They’re either too stupid or too unprincipled to be reliable, trustworthy allies.
There was a Reddit thread where conservatives were asking people on the left, “Is there anything Trump could do to win your support?”, and the answer was almost always no, because even if he completely reversed his position on everything, the damage he’s already done cannot be forgiven. I personally am of the opinion that some crimes or mistakes have such grave consequences and do such horrible damage that the people who commit them should not be given a second chance- that what they did showed us who they truly are, and it can never be unseen. In my opinion, failing to vote against Trump during his second campaign is one of those.
I cannot forgive these people not because I feel malice towards them (although I admittedly do), but because I could not EVER feel safe around them or trust them enough to work together. They are absolutely the sort of people who will turn Nazi the moment the pressure is on, and I have no desire to intermingle with people who will betray us and sell us out- as far as I’m concerned, it’s not speculation that they will do this, they’ve already done it by letting Trump coast right into the White House, and they’d do it again.
This is why the moment I heard Trump had won the popular vote was the death of hope for me- not just because of the horrors that we were now guaranteed to face, but because of the realization that the majority of Americans, not just the MAGA, are complete write-offs and I’d have to be facing those horrors alone, with almost no allies I could trust or depend on.