He was waiting for me at the arranged place. âPunctuality is the politeness of kings, Mister Pendragon,â he sniffed.
I chose to ignore the âMisterâ. âApologies,â I said, saluting with my sword. âThe traffic was a nightmare. But I am here now. Am I addressing the Mr. Collins who I came here to compete with?â
âActually,â he smirked, âitâs âwith whom I came here to competeââ. âAnd I think you will find that, in saluting, the hilt of the sword is brought to the lips by simply pulling the elbow back as the arm is raised.â
The bout had not begun, and already he had me on the defensive. âOh, yeah?â I replied.
âBut wait,â he said, âCome closer. If we are going to have a contest, we need to establish the rules.â
âRules, sir?â I said. âThis is a fight to the death.â
âRight,â he said, âno rulesâ, and unleashed a kick that might have ended the debate on the spot, if I had not taken Hepâs advice and worn an iron codpiece.
âThat was ad hominem,â I objected. âI came here for an argument. That was just abuse.â
âNo it wasnât,â he sneered. His reckless overconfidence was a weapon I could use. I cautiously tested him with a logical feint. âMr. Collins,â I asked, âdo you have any words on that scroll?â
âNo,â he replied smugly.
âMr. Collins,â I asked, âdo you then have some words on that scroll?â
âNo,â he answered again, with a jesuitical smile, falling neatly into my trap.
âMr. Collins,â I asked, âdo you then have words on that scroll?â
âYes, curse it!â he shouted, raising his scroll and trying to poke me in the eye.
âAha!â I cried. âHoist on your own petard!â
âWell actually,â he retorted, âitâs hoist withâŚâ
Battle had now commenced in earnest. I opened with the classics:
âArma virumque cano,â I beganâŚ
âWell actually,â he interrupted aggressively, âthe Latin v is properly pronounced as a w.â
âGood to know, and I thank you,â I replied. âWhen the bards write of this day, and ask me to describe you, my answer will be âwhiney, weedy, weakyâ.â He feigned insouciance, but I saw him flinch.
He recovered quickly, though, and sprang at me, pulling out a copy of On the Origin Of Species and beginning to read. With a quick parry-riposte I returned to the attack with the opening stanzas of the Mabinogion, and we battled back and forth for some time. I recited Talhaiarn from memory, he countered with PhilosophiĂŚ Naturalis Principia Mathematica. I switched to Paradise Lost, he responded with his own synthesis of Alfred North Whitehead and Maimonides (dubious at best).
I could feel myself tiring. All the chanting of choruses and tapping out the metre with my feet was taking its toll. In desperation, I said, âI will now recite the poem that won me second runner-up at the Llangollen Eisteddfod in 1214.â
âA bunch of the boys were whooping it up
In the LlanfairÂpwllgwyngyllÂgogeryÂchwyrnÂdrobwllÂllanÂtysilioÂgogoÂgoch saloonâŚâ
A self-satisfied smirk came over his face, and from his satchel he drew a massive tome. It was the moment I had dreaded, the one no man could prepare for. It was Robert Barclayâs TheologiĂŚ Vere ChristianĂŚ Apologia.
I could feel the weight of the Third, and then the Fourth Proposition pressing me to the ground, and still he read onâthe Fifth, the Sixth. With my last strength I staggered to my feet, but he cast aside the Apologia and, with a triumphant leer, drew out the collected speeches of William Wilberforce. I recoiled, and sagged to the ground again.
Dawn was breaking. As he approached, unrolling his scroll, the morning sun glinted blood-red off its razor edge.