Crititism of terrorism research.
8 Likes
Ancient DNA Reveals Mysterious New Group of Humans in Colombia With No Genetic Ties to People Today
The previously undocumented lineage of hunter-gatherers seems to have disappeared around 2,000 years ago
16 Likes
https://www.science.org/content/article/microbe-bizarrely-tiny-genome-may-be-evolving-virus
Microbe with bizarrely tiny genome may be evolving into a virus
With DNA focused almost entirely on replication, newly discovered organism blurs the line between cells and viruses
17 Likes
I think there was a brief discission of viral origins over at TOP. I remain convinced that âvirusesâ per se are not a valid taxonomic group. They are just âreally small, parasitic, barely living things we donât understand.â If this discovery holds up, it would support that thought. My favorite explaination of the group is that is is a combination of degenerate, parasitic cellular life in DNA viruses (specifically dsDNA viruses), survivors of a pre-DNA RNA dominated world in RNA viruses(specifically ssRNA viruses) and the other 5 classificatoons that i donât have a handy explanation for. @chenille was in on this before as well, and knows more about it than i, though.
18 Likes
14 Likes
14 Likes
I am not an expert, but yeah. The different realms have no genes in common with each other and possibly each of the dozen or so kingdoms might have a separate origin too. Presumably RNA viruses go back to when that was the main genetic material, and retroviruses go back to when DNA was used but not always the master copy.
Exactly where they come from is still another question â parasitic cells that have been stripped down to just a few genes is one possibility, but they could also be pieces of living things. Bacteria have little bits of DNA called plasmids that they share with each other. You could imagine something like that spreading just because it would encourage the host to share more, and eventually forcing the host to share it, and maybe ending up with its own mechanisms to get into less receptive cells. At the very least you might get virioids (infectious RNA with no protein coat) that way.
Evidence is tricky to come by. The last shared ancestor of all living things was already pretty far advanced from the first life, and without even common genes to trace itâs hard to decide what could have come from what. (Not to mention that horizontal transfer can make genes misleading, and it is a serious possibility when it comes to viruses.)
17 Likes
Honestly I think the most likely thing that could go wrong is that it wonât work at all. Everything they said here is genes, genes, genes. Some dark matter to that does something we donât understand. But DNA is treated like code, and once you edit the code you just load it in and it runs. I presume theyâre aware epigenetic factors exist but they obviously think theyâre of secondary concern.
Our bodies are created by epigenetic factors. A zygote needs to start with indicators to let it know which way is up, and that sets off a whole wave of differently expressed genes, like Hox genes that tell your cells where they are in your body. In vertebrates those are activated roughly in sequence â a bunch of things move along the chromosome manipulating histones, preparing each section at the appropriate time. How is that set up? All I know is itâs over my head.
I donât know what kind of plans the scientists involved actually have hereâŚjust when people talk about DNA like code without any mention of how to set up the development environment, it makes me wonder if itâs not over their head too.
15 Likes
Who nerds to worry about epigenetic changes, that just adds more complications! Wait a minute.
Well shit, nope, didnât want to know about that!
11 Likes
And those are the small epigenetic problems. I am expecting âoops all cartilageâ level stuff. How much genetic difference is there between a functioning human body and a formless mass of cancer?
15 Likes
Very, very little difference. Even just coding a protein exactly right in sequence but with one transcriptase slightly off gives you a prion instead of the intended protein.
14 Likes
8 Likes
Oh shit, i had not even considered the potential for prions. So. Many. Prions. Yeah, letâs not.
14 Likes
14 Likes
Not sure where else to put this, soâŚ
5 Likes