The Situation in Israel/Palestine

I missed that he was the ambassador. Or I tried to forget. I swear that the last time I saw him he was flogging Relaxium on TV.

8 Likes

I wish he were still doing that kind of grifting shit. I wish all of these incompetent, violent, genocidal assholes who are fucking giddy over destroying our entire planet were relegated to the absolute fucking margins of society and no one took them seriously, and no one wanted to empower them…

9 Likes
6 Likes
10 Likes

Cross post in world politics

6 Likes
8 Likes

rhetoric dehumanizing Palestinians

Including that oft-fondled phrasing, “I support Israel’s has a right to exist”

–It prioritizes Israeli (and Zionist) comfort at the expense of Palestinian freedom.

–It positions Israel as a normative entity that Palestinians must accept without objection.

–It suggests that Israel is both ancient and timeless.

–It consigns Palestinians to bystanders in their own struggle.

–It unambiguously rebukes anti-Zionism (and anti-Zionists); conversely, it accepts and reinforces the foundational premise of Zionism.

–It implies that genocide is extraneous to the Israeli state or at worst some kind of aberration.

–It intimates, contrary to eight decades of evidence, that Israel can continue to exist without committing genocide.

–It diminishes over a century of Palestinian cultural, intellectual, and political work.

–It indicates that Palestinians and all oppressed groups can be made expendable.

–It emphasizes political abstractions in contrast to the sanctity of human life.

–It bestows on Israel an exceptional status that validates its compulsion to violence.

–It asks the victim to atone for the sins of the oppressor.

–It signals compliance to power for aspiring (or established) politicians. The aspiring politician who affirms Israel’s right to exist is really saying, “You have nothing to worry about with me. I’m not serious about all that ‘socialism’ stuff. I understand the rules you have implemented and I intend to abide by them.”

Not to mention that people who ask about Israel’s right to exist don’t seem especially concerned about Palestine’s existence. This apparent oversight isn’t accidental. The question was designed by the Israeli government to convey hostility under the guise of humanism, and that’s exactly how Palestinians (and Arabs more broadly) receive it: as a duplicitous and tiresome expression of hostility.

11 Likes
7 Likes

Headlines about moods changing when it comes to wars and human rights violations always make me think about past American wars like in Vietnam and Iraq, where people don’t want to admit, even to themselves, that they used to be supporters of the wars. And then I just saw this book in the library which has a title that really nails it:

The title comes from this tweet that I don’t remember seeing at the time, but which strikes me as depressingly accurate:

10 Likes

A lot of people object to this for some understandable reasons. Jewish people were the victim of one of the worst modern atrocities of modern history. And had a long history of persecution, especially in Europe, for their religion and perceived “outsiderness”… But I think part of undoing the absolutely unacceptable position of Jewish people as the eternal “outsider” who is the constant foil to European Christian whiteness is accepting the full humanity of Jewish people… meaning that being a human means being capable of wonderful good and awful evil.

This isn’t to say that “the Jews” are the ones who are carrying out these actions in Gaza. That just plays right into the hands of the antisemites like Mike Huckabee, Trump, the right wing Zionist Christians, etc. It’s the whole “good Jew / bad Jew” framing that objectifies Jewish people and dehumanizes them. The problem is that these right wing Christian Zionist just hate brown people, especially Muslims (who they imagine all Palestinians to do, never mind that many are, in fact Christians) more. But in their mind Jews are “good” when they are doing the things that they want them to do (carrying out a violent war against others in order to ethnically cleanse the land to prepare it for Jesus), and Jews are “bad” when they oppose that war, or the Zionist project in general (which they have twisted to their own eschatological ends that bears little resemblance to Herzl’s secular vision of a Jewish state). Hence, Jews are fully people in their eyes, unless they are doing what they want. It’s more race science shaping their politics here (as much as religion). So, “the Jews” aren’t doing this, a government is doing this. The fact that it’s a state that defines itself as a “Jewish state” is irrelevant. It’s the supremacist ideology that some in Israel have embraced that is the problem.

But we’re all just people, and we’re al capable to great good acts and great evil acts. That’s the nature of peopleness to some degree. People made up all the ideologies, beliefs, religions, etc that drive us to take actions of one kind or another. And we won’t be able to solve these intractable problems (like antisemitism, like islamophobia, like racism, like whatever ism you want to put here) until we understand that fundamentally we’re all people, and one like us doing something bad or evil says nothing about the rest of us… we have to be able to look at events like this and come to a consensus on what it is if we’re to stop it.

I don’t know… whatever the fuck we call this, it has to stop. Gazans are people and whatever members of Hamas did on October 7th doesn’t justify this war. It justifies prosecuting members of Hamas who carried this out, maybe, but it doesn’t justify starving children.

15 Likes
6 Likes

An Op-ed in the NYT about the woman who was shot this week who worked for the Israel embassy, Sarah Milgrim, written by one of her friends. She sounds like a person who really believed that an alternative was possible.

11 Likes

14 Likes
9 Likes

That’s incredibly dark if those survey numbers are accurate.

It’s all terrible, but the stat about 56% of Israelis supporting the forced removal of Arab Israeli citizens is even worse than it might seem at first. From the outside it’s easy for some of us to forget that less than 3/4 of Israeli citizens are Jewish, and about 21% are Arab Israeli. So that would mean that among Jewish Israelis specifically, something closer to 78% of them are in favor of expelling their fellow citizens.

I hope to hell that there was some kind of error in that survey but we’re probably not that lucky.

12 Likes
12 Likes

The IDF says a lot of things it does routinely are “strictly prohibited”.

12 Likes

Yeah, cause they are full of shit, of course.

11 Likes
11 Likes

I hate this woman. does that make me an antisemite?

14 Likes