if they could use their magic and deep pockets to make a deal with Harmy and release his editions, first for a run in theaters and then as an official blu-ray release, they would make soooooo muuuchhhh moneyyyyyy
4 Likes
Iād follow a different line of reasoning with Blade Runner, which also has too many versions
It was not a hit in the theaters, and developed into a cult film based on VHS rentals, I think
Accordingly Iād give the āinternational versionā in the video stores a lot of weight with that one
5 Likes
My copy of Bladerunner has three discs:
one: final cut (2007)
two: original theatrical cut (1982), original international cut (1982) directorās cut (1991)
three: work print and special features
for some reason, it doesnāt have the international directorās cut. Maybe thereās a menu option Iāve overlooked.
4 Likes
The āinternational cutā is what everybody saw on video in the '80s
and the āworkprintā is the only one Iāve ever seen in a theater
so Iām going to go with those two 
3 Likes
Iām waiting for the āOriginal International Final Directorās Cut Work Print.ā
This is the version that reveals that the owl is, in fact, not artificial and Deckard doesnāt like it.
8 Likes
The difference with Blade Runner is that the vast majority of the changes are in editing, not in CGI overprints and replacing sounds which were already in the release version. I know they had Fordās son do some scenes because of missing angles or whatever, but it wasnāt the fundamental change of giving Greedo lines he never had, making him shoot when he didnāt, putting storm troopers on beasts which didnāt exist in the original version, and on and on.
7 Likes
You add voiceovers and a happy ending just to please the audiences who might be confused by the whole thing, and see what they reward you with?
3 Likes
Dollface. All allegory, at double-time.
1 Like
I mostly agree, butā¦ changes to bit characters, for me, were never a huge issueā¦ throw in extra stormtroopers, extra x-wings, whateverā¦ it may or may not be prettier, but as long as it doesnāt change the imbalance of the sidesā¦
Changing a fundamental pivot point of a character, thoughā¦ thatās an issue. Especially when said character goes through the rest of the movie (and further ones) saying theyāre looking out for themselves. Putting Solo in a position where a bounty hunter has all but directly told him that heās about to die, and then somehow claiming that itās more true to the character that he not shoot first just makes the rest of his actions in the movie make very little sense. Thereās any number of points of the original trilogy that rely on him being at least a somewhat ambiguous character, and shoehorning in that one āself defenseā thing really minimizes the rest.
And using that absolutely stupid CGI jerk to the side, and then keeping it even though technology is so much better nowā¦
4 Likes
IIRC, the international cuts were bloodier than the domestic cuts. Which is not to say that you havenāt seen them-- just that two different levels of gore were prepared.
2 Likes
I mean some of the recuts changed the film pretty substantially but I largely give it a pass since it was just rejiggering what was already there versus going in and digitally altering things.
I mean on the one hand I get that Lucas wanted to fix all the things that he never had the time and budget to get right originally. Things like hiding obvious wires, making the light sabers look better, and so on arenāt really things I can protest (although I understand the desire for āpurityā since the originals with all their flaws have a charm of their own). But he just couldnāt stop there and kept messing with things that didnāt need messing with.
4 Likes
So, two episodes into The Mandalorian, and Iām on board. Good low-stakes adventures that tie into the larger picture. And that bountyā¦
2 Likes
6 Likes
Yes! Especially when the justification is something like, āwell we shot that scene, but it got edited outā.
THINGS GET EDITED OUT FOR GOOD REASONS, GEORGE.
6 Likes
Sad as it is, few actually want to see the ādefinitiveā 4 hour cut of a film. For one that I really love I would, because Iām a film nerd, but most donāt have the time or patience. Thereās usually a good reason for leaving scenes out. I rarely watch the deleted scenes for a movie and think to myself, āhot damn what were they thinking by leaving that out!ā
7 Likes
Finished watching two seasons of Shtisel, a well-acted Israeli show about a Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) family in Jerusalem. The characters are human and relatable, especially the boundary-pushing by the younger generation, but the culture they are trying to navigate is (to me) as alien as anything on Star Trek.
Apparently this was a huge hit in Israel, even watched by Haredim, who arenāt supposed to have TVs.
3 Likes
Totally agree, although I really would love to see the 5 hour version of Wim Wendersā Until the End of the World. Having seen the cinematic release version, I think it would have worked much better as a miniseries.
3 Likes
At least the miniseries version of Yor, the Hunter from the Future got a release.
2 Likes
Not often you see that many phallic rock formations all in one place.
3 Likes
We didnāt have anything to compare it to, but yes, the VHS version left nothing to the imagination
2 Likes